Saturday, November 12, 2016

A Post-Election Email Exchange on Academia and Politics

Since Tuesday, I've been thinking about what we could be doing better--in terms of encouraging civil participation, in terms of satisfying the needs of the people who did participate in the last election. I don't yet have fully-formed thoughts, but in the meantime here's a recent email exchange.

--

from:Jean Yang
to:Robert M Ochshorn,
Chinmay Kulkarni
date:Fri, Nov 11, 2016 at 8:27 AM
subject:Academia and politics

In an email thread the other day, a colleague wondered whether we should be more like the "universities of the 60s" and take a more active role in politics. I had thought then that this wasn't the case, that the issue was these rural voters we couldn't reach, but then I learned that only 1/3 of millenials voted. I came upon this thread on Twitter today:
https://twitter.com/FuckTheory
It's not *quite* my experience, but I think it's useful to talk more about the politics associated with science, and not just the politics of how we talk about science.

An underlying theme of my seminar has been "politics is everything," but previously the scope had been limited to discussing why papers were written the way they were, why certain papers were considered important, the actual impact of papers with respect to some notion of "real world." Yesterday we spent the first thirty minutes talking about the election, and I made a point to talk about the mechanics of the electoral system the way we've been talking about the mechanics of the publication system--something I've gotten pretty worked up about is voter protections. Later we talked about the relationship between science and funding, and how projects could be for both good (e.g. curing disease) and sinister (e.g. surveillance) purposes. The students seemed to appreciate this discussion, and my one student had that nice quote: "We may be solving biological cancer and creating a social cancer."
I previously didn't know how far to push things when it came to talking about the social aspects of science, especially since this is a class in the Computer Science Department, but the students have seemed to appreciate it when I've talked about systems, hierarchies, and the underlying reasons things happen the way they do. I've been thinking about how to connect my relatively narrow academic activism to more generalizable messages and lessons for students who are going to graduate and be the technical/scientific elite.

--
Jean Yang
website | twitter

--

from:Chinmay Kulkarni
to:Jean Yang,
cc:Robert M Ochshorn
date:Fri, Nov 11, 2016 at 10:13 AM
subject:Re: Academia and politics

Activist campuses are great, if they know what they are activating. The 60s coalesced around peace and civil rights, but what do we want now?

I've been reading a lot into social disenfranchisement, and I worry that things are only going to get worse. Automation is an exponential process, so we're kinda screwed if we don't figure out what people who don't have jobs should do. 

To me, this translates to two actionable things:
1. We've got to start teaching students to take initiative. You can't be the elite if you are a cog. We've got to start thinking about how to make students more entrepreneurial so they don't have to face a time when they have no "job"
2. we are currently letting mathematicians and engineers run the world without a clue about how to reason about ethics or about the social fabric that ties us together. That has to stop. We've got to go beyond "You just tell me the utility and I'll maximise it" to one that is a lot more examined. Otherwise the masses who get left behind are going to be (rightly) electing Trumpian candidates.  
3. Finally I agree with your actions. Academics got divorced from morality as a result of governmental crackdowns on activist campuses: http://www.irwinator.com/124/123.htm And look where it's got us. We cannot train an intellectual elite without moral values.

Chinmay

14 comments:

Sophie Grace said...

Your article is very interesting and fantastic, at the same time the theme is unique and perfect, great job. Help create a new stuff pack for sims 4 cheats. Art & Crafts? Science? Fun tech? Self-care? Happy haunts? They are all possible stuff packs.

Street View Online said...

What a great and interesting post.

Rona Wedmore said...

I think this is brilliant post Your article may be very interesting and first rate, at the equal time https://masteressaywriters.co.uk/blogs/argumentative-essay-topics-to-help-you-kickstart-your-essay the subject matter is precise and best, outstanding task. Help create a new stuff.

Maariah said...

Your blog is usually totally interesting i install it without a doubt info chafe pertaining to putting up. Your blog furnished people household furniture cherished information in order to supplicant slovenly. Floorboards determine eases of your respective poll tend to be huge. vegan protein

Anonymous said...

Appreciate the post! Happy to join the discussion. In case you are looking for a professional writer, check the following service https://best-writing-service.com/. Hope you will be satisfied with cooperation.

Okseoabhinav said...

Thank you very much giving us to express our feeling and thoughts about above information. I think you will keep updating and changing these information time to time if there is need to change. Transaction And Valuation Services, Audit Firms In India, Business Setup Services In India, Accounting Services, Forensic Accounting and Fraud Detection.

cacpvtltd said...

Thanks for this blog. It really provides awesome information to all readers. keep it up and keep posting these types of blogs on digital marketing services, it's really helpful.
Corporate Consultancy Services Delhi

Anuj Gold said...

have you ever heard about Reecan which known for its Luxury office furniture with interior

renovation for the commercial or residential places. Nowadays office are more modern and

spacious. reecan gives you home more robust architecture.
Luxury office furniture in delhi

riya said...

Everyone should know about the vastu because it makes you life and future better, there are

some principles which everyone to need to follow it, the followers of vastu shastra are

prosperous and safe.


Vastu Consultant
Vastu Experts
Vastu Consultants
Southern Hemisphere Vastu
Vastu in Southern Hemisphere
Vastu for Southern Hemisphere

jonjones said...

Submitting an essay is coming soon and you haven't prepared at all? In that case, I think you should take advantage of this prime essays and pass your essay work perfectly! Go and don't waste your time!

Himesh Raja said...

If you feel like you have lost the zeal and intimacy of your sexual life then a reliable sexologist in Delhi is something that you certainly need. He has registered himself in the list of the top reputed sexologist. You have got it here! He is an honorable name in the industry of sexologist treatment and best sexologist in Delhi or top sexologist in Faridabad.

Mrjack said...


It's really an amazing content and i felt it's very valueable after reading it. I bookmarked it due to its content quality. If you want to know about leather jackets then goto Leather men's racer jacket!

Anmol Verma said...

If you feel like you have lost the zeal and intimacy of your sexual life then a reliable sexologist treatment in Delhi is something that you certainly need. Hakim Hari Kishan Lal has registered itself in the list of the top reputed sexologist in Delhi. With decades-old experience and tested expertise, our sexologist clinic in Delhi has treated several physical dysfunctions amongst the patients. So If you want to tempt the pleasure back to your married life then this is your chance to get your hands on the best sexologist in Delhi.
sexologist in delhi sexologist in new delhi sexologist in gurgaon sexologist in faridabad sexologist in noida sexologist in ghaziabad sexologist in east patel nagar

Rite Way Towing & Recovery Inc said...

schedule for providing services, but Riteway car battery jump service will always be happy to provide you assistance